Am I ‘Disabled’ if I Cannot Find Work?

Am I ‘Disabled’ if I Cannot Find Work?

A layoff or an employer’s downsizing can present an older worker with grim choices: should the worker attempt to find a new job? Or should the worker attempt to draw retirement benefits, knowing that doing so can result in financial consequences? For some older workers, a layoff or downsizing can result in an attempt to claim disability benefits. By claiming that a medical or mental condition impairs their ability to work, they claim that even if they could continue working at their former job, there are not enough of such jobs available for them. Does such an argument work? The U.S. Supreme Court answered this question in the 2003 case Barnhart v. Thomas.

Five-Step Disability Determination

In determining whether an individual is eligible for Social Security disability benefits, the Social Security Administration (SSA) uses a five-step determination process:

  1. Are you working?  If you are working and such work is considered “substantial gainful activity” – that is, if you make more than $1,090 per month – then you will not be considered disabled.
  2. Is your condition (physically and/or mentally) “severe”? In other words, does your condition interfere with your ability to perform work-related activities? If not, then the SSA will not find you to be disabled.
  3. Do you have a condition that is found on the list of disabling conditions? This list contains various conditions that the SSA considers to be so severe that a person who has such a condition is considered disabled. If your condition is not on the list, the SSA considers whether your specific condition or conditions is equal in severity to a condition that is on the list. If the SSA finds that it is not, the inquiry continues.
  4. Can you perform any of your prior work? If you cannot perform any of your prior work, the inquiry continues to Step 5. If the SSA finds you can perform your prior work, you are not considered disabled.
  5. Can you perform any other work? Taking into consideration the particulars of your situation and condition, the SSA will consider if there are any jobs of sufficient number in the national economy that you are able to perform. If there are, then you will not be found to be disabled.

Thomas’ Argument and the Supreme Court’s Ruling

In Thomas, the claimant Ms. Thomas worked as an elevator operator for several years until her position was eventually eliminated. She then filed for disability benefits, claiming that hypertension, cardiac arrhythmia, and cervical and lumbar strains and sprains kept her from being able to work. She claimed further that she was unable to return to her previous job because there were not enough such jobs in the national economy. The U.S. Supreme Court rejected Thomas’ argument based upon the language of the Social Security Act. In particular, the Court found that the plain language of the statute did not require a claimant’s prior work to exist in sufficient numbers. So long as a claimant is able to perform his or her prior job – regardless of whether such work actually exists – he or she will be denied benefits. Although the five-step process seems simple, the fate of your disability benefits claim can turn on facts that may at first appear to be inconsequential. Let us assist with your Social Security disability benefits claim by contacting the Klok Law Firm LLC today for a free consultation. Call us at (843) 216-8860.

25 Comments
  • 醫學美容-泰國-活力-cosmetic-wiki
    Posted at 00:21h, 27 October

    完美妝感 ~【UNT】輕透絲絨感持久粉底 & 狠狠吻我絲光唇膏 @ 潮流、美妝、消費 創造個人化風格的女性社群 PIXstyleMe 完美妝感 ~【UNT】輕透絲絨感持久粉底 & 狠狠吻我絲光唇膏

  • Football Solutions Double blow for Mönchengladbach
    Posted at 05:06h, 05 November

    Chelsea assistant manager Ray Wilkins has vehemently denied ‘player power’ was responsible for getting Luiz Felipe Scolari sacked and insists there are no rifts at Stamford Bridge. Player power didn’t give Scolari the axe and there’s no split at Chelsea, Wilkins rages

  • futbol.run Netherlands on a high as Russia seek to respond - News
    Posted at 18:20h, 21 November

    Arsenal will win the Europa League if Mesut Ozil can replicate his performance from the first leg of their quarter final against CSKA Moscow, according to Sportsmail columnist Martin Keown. Mesut Ozil needs to ‘bottle’ his display against CSKA Moscow and deliver it again if Arsenal are to win the Europa League, insists Martin Keown

  • Teige
    Posted at 03:45h, 18 January

    Your article pecrfetly shows what I needed to know, thanks!

  • SammyTwerm
    Posted at 16:19h, 01 March

    Read our in-depth iPhone XS Max review
    Read our hands-on iPhone XR review
    link
    Read our hands-on Apple Watch 4 review
    iPhone XS price and release date
    iPhone XS

  • Fanny Macbeth
    Posted at 19:34h, 05 March

    Nearly all of what you assert happens to be supprisingly precise and that makes me ponder why I had not looked at this with this light previously. This particular article truly did turn the light on for me personally as far as this particular topic goes. But there is one point I am not too comfortable with so while I make an effort to reconcile that with the core idea of your position, let me observe just what the rest of your visitors have to say.Well done.

  • Georgetoott
    Posted at 23:23h, 06 March

    Los Blancos, with captain Sergio Ramos suspended after deliberately collecting a yellow card in the first leg, had been looking to build on a slender 2-1 lead from that game in Amsterdam and stay on course for a potential fourth straight European triumph.

    However, after Raphael Varane’s header rattled the crossbar, Ajax raced into an early lead through Hakim Ziyech before Dusan Tadic set up David Neres for a second in the 18th minute.
    tinyurl
    Real Madrid were forced into two changes when Lucas Vazquez and Vinicius Junior went off injured, with substitute Gareth Bale hitting the post just before half-time.

    Ajax looked to have put the tie to bed when Tadic swept in a brilliant third goal just after the hour – which was eventually given following an extensive Video Assistant Referee review to check if the ball had gone out of play in the build-up.

  • Anthonydum
    Posted at 20:33h, 08 March

    Inter Rapid Wien live score (and video online live stream*) starts on 21.2.2019. at 20:00 UTC time at San Siro/Giuseppe Meazza stadium, Milan, Italy in UEFA Europa League, Knockout stage – Europe. Here on SofaScore livescore you can find all Inter vs Rapid Wien previous results sorted by their H2H matches. Links to Inter vs. Rapid Wien video highlights are collected in the Media tab for the most popular matches as soon as video appear on video hosting sites like Youtube or Dailymotion. We’re not responsible for any video content, please contact video file owners or hosters for any legal complaints tinyurl.

  • DerekUphor
    Posted at 21:02h, 10 March

    Ernest Quintana, 78, was at Kaiser Permanente Medical Center in Fremont when a doctor – appearing on the robot’s screen – informed him that he would die within a few days.

    A family friend wrote on social media that it was “not the way to show value and compassion to a patient“.

    The hospital says it “regrets falling short” of the family’s expectations.

    Mr Quintana died the next day.

  • Henryduppy
    Posted at 20:04h, 12 March

    Theresa May says she has secured “legally binding” changes to her Brexit deal, a day ahead of MPs voting on it.

    But European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker” warned if the deal was voted down there was “no third chance”.

    They spoke at a joint press conference in Strasbourg after a late meeting.

  • Henryduppy
    Posted at 21:02h, 14 March

    These three figures — William Rick Singer, Mark Riddell and Rudolph Meredith, respectively — are at the center of the nationwide scandal in which 33 parents are accused of using their wealth and means to help their children game the college admissions system.
    But those three names do not appear anywhere in the complaint text, though the document gives enough clues to make clear who is who. Instead, they are named as Cooperating Witness 1, 2 and 3, and each agreed to plead guilty and to cooperate with the government in the hope of obtaining leniency when they are sentenced, the complaint says.

  • FrankCal
    Posted at 19:13h, 16 March

    Trump was surrounded at Friday’s event by officials from Customs and Border Protection as well as surviving family members of those who have loved ones killed by undocumented immigrants. Attorney General William Barr was also at the President’s veto event.
    While some lawmakers including some Republicans — have argued against the President’s use of national emergency powers in this instance, the Justice Department set forth a robust defense of the President’s authority to do so in a letter to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell earlier this month, according to a copy obtained by CNN on Friday.
    “The President acted well within his discretion in declaring a national emergency concerning the southern border,” wrote Assistant Attorney General Stephen Boyd, setting out the legal basis for the proclamation under the National Emergencies Act and additional statutory authorities, which largely tracks an internal memo issued by the Office of Legal Counsel at the Justice Department.

  • Jesseben
    Posted at 07:15h, 19 March

    On how she landed on her direction in life:

    “I always knew I was meant to be working in art, I just never knew how. In school, was so confused and always switched my majors around. In 2015, I decided to take a break from school to help out at home and that’s when I discovered my passion for fashion illustration. I drew/a> an illustration of Jhene Aiko and she liked it on Instagram. It kind of grew from there.”

  • RodneyRuh
    Posted at 05:57h, 26 March

    Christina was born in the royal castle Tre Kronor on 18 December S. 8 December] 1626. Her parents were the Swedish king Gustavus Adolphus and his German wife, Maria Eleonora, had already had two daughters—a stillborn princess in 1620, and then the first Princess Christina, who was born in 1623 and died the following year.3] Excited expectation surrounded Maria Eleonora’s third pregnancy in 1626. When the baby was born, it was first thought to be a boy as it was “hairy” and screamed “with a strong, hoarse voice.”she later wrote in her autobiography that, “Deep embarrassment spread among the women when they discovered their mistake.” The king, though, was very happy, stating, “She’ll be clever, she has made fools of us all!”6] From most accounts, Gustav Adolf appears to have been closely attached to his daughter, and she appears to have admired him greatly.

  • RichardNab
    Posted at 05:29h, 29 March

    A court has ruled that the building is illegal, and the €57 million ($64 million) Chateau Diter will now have to be knocked down.
    Property developer Pierre Diter, who owns the chateau in the town of Grasse, in Southern France, has 18 months to raze the building and faces a fine of €200,000 ($226,000), Pierre-Jean Gaury, attorney general at the court of appeal in Aix-en-Provence, told CNN.
    “Patrick Diter was accused of having executed important works on a land without authorization,” said Gaury.

  • HerbertChuts
    Posted at 23:41h, 04 April

    Despite residing in Germany for nearly 30 years, there are still some things I cannot wrap my mind around. I may have married a German, pay German taxes, and have German(-American) children, but I guess my US mentality still shines through.

    Like when it comes to personal space. I’ll be standing in the supermarket, in front of a shelf full of products, deliberating over the selection, and inevitably a hand will slip itself in front of my face and grab an item from the row. Many Germans seem to not have any qualms about this at all, but it still takes me aback sometimes.

  • EdwardTam
    Posted at 03:23h, 08 April

    French President Emmanuel Macron has appointed a panel of experts to investigate France’s actions during the Rwandan genocide 25 years ago on April 7.

    Macron has also met representatives of a group of survivors in. Paris

  • CharlesKal
    Posted at 00:45h, 09 April

    Rai News: il primo canale all news italiano. Scopri le ultime notizie in tempo reale. News e aggiornamenti su politica, cronaca, esteri, economia, sport e attualita.

  • CharlesKal
    Posted at 15:12h, 11 April

    Ryska militarfartyg kommer till Filippinerna samtidigt som spanningen okar kring Sydkinesiska sjon. Men framfor allt expanderar nu Kina langt us i Stilla havet. Det vacker oro i USA eftersom Kina anses hota de amerikanska ubatar som ar helt avgorande vid en konflikt.

  • Rickyhem
    Posted at 14:18h, 13 April

    The Portuguese road Prevention agency (PRP) has this week called for more and improved traffic stops in Portugal. The agency has also deemed current actions by law enforcement officials as ineffective in dealing with the majority of serious traffic offences.

  • Phillipnig
    Posted at 12:19h, 15 April

    xxx

  • Barrybar
    Posted at 06:46h, 18 April

    The series of conversations with the Warsaw Ghetto survivors was conducted to commemorate the 76 th anniversary of the outbreak of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising that falls on the 19th of April.

  • NelsonAnams
    Posted at 17:02h, 19 April

    text messaging, or texting, is the act of composing and sending electronic messages, typically consisting of alphabetic and numeric characters, between two or more users of mobile devices, desktops/laptops, or other type of compatible computer.

  • RichardVub
    Posted at 00:18h, 22 April

Post A Comment