If the Engagement is Off, Who Owns the Ring?

If the Engagement is Off, Who Owns the Ring?

The proposal is one of the most important moments for a couple. The proposal and the accompanying ring invokes the concept that the couple, at that moment, has decided to take their single but together status, and become a legally-bound unit through the act of getting married. The engagement ring is a symbol of the upcoming nuptials and is considered to have an extremely high value, not just sentimentally, but also financially. With such expensive jewelry on the line, what happens if the couple decides not to get married? Who owns the ring at the time the couple splits?

Historical “Fault-Based” Assessments Regarding the Ownership of the Ring

In recent history, there was a sentimentality by the courts of what an engagement and marriage mean to society as a whole. There were laws that permitted someone who was broken up with to sue for the emotional damage that was caused pursuant to the break-up. Though “heartbalm” litigation is no longer the law of the land, there is still monetary value with regards to the ring and the breakup of the couple before the marriage that goes beyond sentimentality into the land of expenses, property, and monetary damage. In British common law (which has little bearing on the law of the land in the United States, but British common law was considered when American law was starting to form), the courts analyzed the fault of the parties before determining who owned the ring. Because the ring was considered to be a promise to wed, the person who broke that promise would lose the ring; in other words, the innocent party would keep the ring.

Engagement Ring Law Theories Throughout the United States

The engagement ring law varies from state-to-state with states evaluating possession of the engagement ring based on the following theories:

  • The person who broke up the engagement loses ownership of the ring
  • The ring is considered to be an absolute gift, therefore the recipient of the ring gets to keep it
  • The ring represents the promise to wed, and if there is no wedding, regardless of the fault, the ring is returned to the person who purchased it
  • The ownership of the ring is dependent on the totality of the circumstances and must be decided on a case-by-case basis

South Carolina’s Engagement Ring Caselaw

In South Carolina, the South Carolina Court of Appeals dealt with the issue of ownership and possession of the ring at the time of the breakup. In a case known as Campbell v. Robinson, the Court of Appeals came to the decision first and foremost that fault would not be the determining factor relating to the right of ownership. It moved further that gift law would determine who had the legal right to the ring. In other words, the final determination of who owned the ring depends largely on the type of gift that the ring represents.

Because the ring was an engagement ring, it holds the conditional promise that by receiving the ring, there is a condition that acceptance of the ring means there is a promise to wed. Though no one can be forced into marrying, if the marriage does not take place, and the ring is conditional on getting married, then the ring is owned by the original giver. However, if there is additional evidence that could show that the ring has more significance than just an engagement ring and that it is not conditional on marrying, then the ring is considered to be an absolute gift, and the receiver can keep the ring.

Experienced Family Law Attorneys in Mount Pleasant, Charleston Area

Marriage comes with it significant issues that must be discussed and understood before deciding to wed. An experienced family law attorney at Klok Law Firm LLC can provide guidance on several ways to legally protect yourself before saying “I do”. Contact Klok Law Firm LLC today for a free and confidential consultation.

  • Football Solutions Yatran-Basis Uman
    Posted at 23:14h, 07 November

    Fulham are to make a renewed bid to sign Manchester City striker Roque Santa Cruz after he declared his intent to leave. The 29-year-old has been dogged by injury. Fulham back in for Manchester City striker Roque Santa Cruz as he issues come and get me plea

  • futbol.run Women's EURO - Mélanie Fischer
    Posted at 02:10h, 21 November

    SAM CUNNINGHAM: Hiddink is considering a ‘six or seven aside’ match, possibly later in the week, at their Cobham training base to test Terry’s fitness for the Champions League clash with PSG. John Terry will struggle to break up Branislav Ivanovic and Gary Cahill, says Chelsea boss Guus Hiddink

  • Austgex
    Posted at 10:57h, 20 April

    Real Doxycycline Drugs Shipped Ups online pharmacy Lasix Usa Amoxicillin Adverse

  • Austgex
    Posted at 01:45h, 23 April

    Viagra For Sale With Debit Card cialis Pediatric Zithromax Who Makes Amoxicillin

  • dortmund drakt
    Posted at 09:07h, 04 May

    Hi there are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world
    but I’m trying to get started and set up my own. Do you need any
    coding knowledge to make your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!
    dortmund drakt

  • Austgex
    Posted at 23:33h, 13 May

    Viagra Welche Dosierung Fausse Couche Sous Cytotec viagra Pastilla Cialis Viagra Priligy Farmacias Chile

  • Maglietta Wilson
    Posted at 12:56h, 14 May

    Thanks for sharing your info. I really appreciate your efforts and I am
    waiting for your next write ups thanks once again. Maglietta Wilson

  • Malgia Roma
    Posted at 04:36h, 15 May

    Hello Dear, are you in fact visiting this website on a regular basis, if so then you
    will without doubt get nice experience. Malgia Roma

  • Austgex
    Posted at 06:35h, 15 May

    Amoxil De Haute Qualite Viagra Pas Cher Payement Securise In Canada online pharmacy Priligy Legal Australia Order Generic Accutane Cialis Ricetta

  • Juventus Drakt
    Posted at 22:38h, 15 May

    I think that is among the such a lot important info for me.

    And i’m happy studying your article. But should observation on few common things, The
    site taste is wonderful, the articles is really excellent : D.
    Excellent activity, cheers Juventus Drakt

  • Atletico Madrid Tröja
    Posted at 05:40h, 16 May

    This design is steller! You obviously know
    how to keep a reader entertained. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job.
    I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.
    Too cool! Atletico Madrid Tröja

  • Günstige Barcelona Juan Miranda Fußballtrikots
    Posted at 20:39h, 16 May

    Howdy! I understand this is kind of off-topic however I needed to ask.
    Does running a well-established website such as yours require a massive amount work?
    I am completely new to writing a blog however I do write
    in my journal daily. I’d like to start a blog so I can easily share my experience and
    views online. Please let me know if you have any ideas or tips for brand new aspiring bloggers.
    Appreciate it! Günstige Barcelona Juan Miranda Fußballtrikots

  • maglie calcio bambino
    Posted at 00:58h, 31 May

    Thanks for some other wonderful post. The place else may just anyone
    get that kind of information in such an ideal approach of writing?

    I’ve a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such info.
    maglie calcio bambino

  • Matundund
    Posted at 04:59h, 01 June

    Does Keflex Help Bronchitis order cialis online Prednisone Canadian Pharmacy

  • Billige olympique lyonnais drakt
    Posted at 11:42h, 01 June

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on billige fotballdrakter.
    Regards Billige olympique lyonnais drakt

  • Rebexinly
    Posted at 17:36h, 01 June

    Cialis Dove Acquistarlo Pharmacy The Best Nitroglycerin Precio Priligy Farmacias Espanolas

  • Austgex
    Posted at 03:41h, 08 June

    Shop Cialis Online cialis Low Prices Flagyl In Stamford Propecia Hormones Women What Is Ephadraxin

  • Matundund
    Posted at 04:36h, 08 June

    Amoxicillin Safety Dosing For Dogs generic cialis from india Amoxicillin Allergy Crohn’S Rx Express Online

  • Austgex
    Posted at 07:05h, 09 June

    Order Fluexotine Online Do You Need A Prescription For Estrace viagra online Real Viagra Pfizer

  • Rebexinly
    Posted at 04:43h, 13 June

    Generic Isotretinoin Pills Best Website Cheapeast Saturday Delivery Ciprofloxacin Pi Prix Cialis Montreal canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg Non Us Pharmacies Medsforless Commander Clomid

  • Matundund
    Posted at 14:00h, 15 June

    isotretinoin 10mg discount ups without perscription with free shipping canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg Buy Cialis Online Safely Cialis Generika 20mg Bestellen

  • roblox executor
    Posted at 00:23h, 17 June

    Me enjoying, will read more. Thanks!

  • proxo key generator
    Posted at 07:50h, 19 June

    I must say, as a lot as I enjoyed reading what you had to say, I couldnt help but lose interest after a while.

Post A Comment